Opinion
Why Conservatives Are Happier Than Liberals
By ARTHUR C. BROOKS
WHO is happier about life — liberals or conservatives? The answer might seem straightforward. After all, there is an entire academic literature in the social sciences dedicated to showing conservatives as naturally authoritarian, dogmatic, intolerant of ambiguity, fearful of threat and loss, low in self-esteem and uncomfortable with complex modes of thinking. And it was the candidate Barack Obama in 2008 who infamously labeled blue-collar voters “bitter,” as they “cling to guns or religion.” Obviously, liberals must be happier, right?
- Wrong. Scholars on both the left and right have studied this question extensively, and have reached a consensus that it is conservatives who possess the happiness edge. Many data sets show this. For example, the Pew Research Center in 2006 reported that conservative Republicans were 68 percent more likely than liberal Democrats to say they were “very happy” about their lives. This pattern has persisted for decades. The question isn’t whether this is true, but why.
Many conservatives favor an explanation focusing on lifestyle
differences, such as marriage and faith. They note that most
conservatives are married; most liberals are not. (The percentages are
53 percent to 33 percent, according to my calculations using data from
the 2004 General Social Survey, and almost none of the gap is due to
the fact that liberals tend to be younger than conservatives.) Marriage
and happiness go together. If two people are demographically the same
but one is married and the other is not, the married person will be 18
percentage points more likely to say he or she is very happy than the
unmarried person.
The story on religion is much the same. According to the Social Capital
Community Benchmark Survey, conservatives who practice a faith
outnumber religious liberals in America nearly four to one. And the
link to happiness? You guessed it. Religious participants are nearly
twice as likely to say they are very happy about their lives as are
secularists (43 percent to 23 percent). The differences don’t depend on
education, race, sex or age; the happiness difference exists even when
you account for income.
Whether religion and marriage should make people happy is a question
you have to answer for yourself. But consider this: Fifty-two percent
of married, religious, politically conservative people (with kids) are
very happy — versus only 14 percent of single, secular, liberal people
without kids.
An explanation for the happiness gap more congenial to liberals is that
conservatives are simply inattentive to the misery of others. If they
recognized the injustice in the world, they wouldn’t be so cheerful. In
the words of Jaime Napier and John Jost, New York University
psychologists, in the journal Psychological Science,
“Liberals may be less happy than conservatives because they are less
ideologically prepared to rationalize (or explain away) the degree of
inequality in society.” The academic parlance for this is “system
justification.”
The data show that conservatives do indeed see the free enterprise
system in a sunnier light than liberals do, believing in each
American’s ability to get ahead on the basis of achievement. Liberals
are more likely to see people as victims of circumstance and
oppression, and doubt whether individuals can climb without
governmental help. My own analysis using 2005 survey data from Syracuse
University shows that about 90 percent of conservatives agree that
“While people may begin with different opportunities, hard work and
perseverance can usually overcome those disadvantages.” Liberals — even
upper-income liberals — are a third less likely to say this.
So conservatives are ignorant, and ignorance is bliss, right? Not so fast, according to a study
from the University of Florida psychologists Barry Schlenker and John
Chambers and the University of Toronto psychologist Bonnie Le in the
Journal of Research in Personality. These scholars note that liberals
define fairness and an improved society in terms of greater economic
equality. Liberals then condemn the happiness of conservatives, because
conservatives are relatively untroubled by a problem that, it turns
out, their political counterparts defined.
Imagine the opposite. Say liberals were the happy ones. Conservatives
might charge that it is only because liberals are unperturbed by the
social welfare state’s monstrous threat to economic liberty. Liberals
would justifiably dismiss this argument as solipsistic and silly.
There is one other noteworthy political happiness gap that has gotten
less scholarly attention than conservatives versus liberals: moderates
versus extremists.
Political moderates must be happier than extremists, it always seemed
to me. After all, extremists actually advertise their misery with
strident bumper stickers that say things like, “If you’re not outraged,
you’re not paying attention!”
But it turns out that’s wrong. People at the extremes are happier than
political moderates. Correcting for income, education, age, race,
family situation and religion, the happiest Americans are those who say
they are either “extremely conservative” (48 percent very happy) or
“extremely liberal” (35 percent). Everyone else is less happy, with the
nadir at dead-center “moderate” (26 percent).
What explains this odd pattern? One possibility is that extremists have
the whole world figured out, and sorted into good guys and bad guys.
They have the security of knowing what’s wrong, and whom to fight. They
are the happy warriors.
Whatever the explanation, the implications are striking. The Occupy
Wall Street protesters may have looked like a miserable mess. In truth,
they were probably happier than the moderates making fun of them from
the offices above. And none, it seems, are happier than the Tea
Partiers, many of whom cling to guns and faith with great tenacity.
Which some moderately liberal readers of this newspaper might find
quite depressing.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/08/opinion/sunday/conservatives-are-happier-and-extremists-are-happiest-of-all.html?_r=1
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/08/opinion/sunday/conservatives-are-happier-and-extremists-are-happiest-of-all.html?_r=1
No comments:
Post a Comment